Skip to podcast content

GLP-1 Hub Podcast

How to Support Someone Taking a GLP-1: Lessons from Dave Knapp

By the GLP-1 Hub editorial teamArticle published With Dave KnappEpisode released December 15, 2025

Dave Knapp shares how weight cycling, diabetes and stigma shaped On The Pen, with practical lessons for supporting a loved one using GLP-1 medication.

Listen to this episode

The GLP-1 Hub Podcast

Open episode on Buzzsprout

If someone you love starts a GLP-1 medication, useful support begins with understanding what they are treating and asking what help they want. A new prescription is not an invitation to evaluate their portions, demand a weight update or compare their experience with someone else’s.

Dave Knapp, creator of On The Pen and author of Decoding GLP-1, brings a personal perspective to that conversation. Speaking with Ana Reisdorf, he describes years of weight cycling, a type 2 diabetes diagnosis and the change from resisting medication to helping other people navigate treatment. His story shows how much can sit behind a seemingly simple decision to take a prescription.

Learn the history before offering another diet

Knapp remembers losing weight on a low-carbohydrate diet in high school. The early result made the approach feel like an answer he should be able to repeat. Over the following years, he describes returning to it, losing some weight and then regaining more.

After his diabetes diagnosis, he tried another structured ketogenic program. In his account, his A1C improved substantially over a year while his weight changed from about 319 to 312 pounds. The experience challenged his assumption that controlling one part of his health would necessarily resolve every other concern.

That is his history, not a comparison trial of diets and medicines. It explains why hearing the same advice again could feel discouraging, even when the person offering it means well. Before suggesting an approach, ask whether the person wants ideas or simply wants you to understand what they have already tried.

You do not need to agree on a single explanation for the past to offer support now. You can recognize that the person has spent time, money and effort on their health without turning their history into an argument about whether they tried hard enough.

Weight and blood sugar are different parts of the care plan

Knapp’s account makes a useful distinction for family members: the scale cannot tell you everything about diabetes treatment. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases explains that A1C reflects average blood glucose over roughly three months and helps clinicians monitor diabetes and make treatment decisions. It is not a weight measurement.

A person’s goals may include glucose management, weight, tolerability and other health concerns. You may not know which is most important at a particular visit, and you do not need access to all their results to respect the plan.

If they want your help preparing for an appointment, ask what has been difficult and what they want to discuss. Avoid deciding that a prescription is unnecessary because their body looks a certain way or that it has failed because their weight changed less than someone else’s. Those are care decisions that require more context.

Respect privacy without treating the medication as a secret to expose

As his online community grew, Knapp was surprised by how many people had not told friends or family they were using medication. Some were tired of announcing another weight-loss effort. Others expected judgment about taking an easy way out.

That observation helped shape his book for friends and family. He wanted a readable explanation of both the lived experience and the treatment conversation, including ways to begin a discussion and respond with compassion.

A supporter can make disclosure easier without requiring it. Ask whether the person wants to talk, accept a limited answer and let them decide who else knows. Sharing their treatment at a family gathering or explaining their weight change to someone else removes a choice that belongs to them.

If you are the person taking medication, you can explain as much or as little as feels appropriate. You might want practical help from one trusted person while keeping the wider conversation private. You do not have to become a public advocate to deserve care.

Good intentions still need a check-in

Knapp says some of the weight comments that stayed with him came from people who intended to help. He does not interpret every hurtful remark as deliberate cruelty. That leaves room to change the conversation without dismissing its effect.

Instead of assuming a compliment will land well, ask which kinds of encouragement the person finds useful. Some may want to celebrate a health milestone. Others may want meals and family visits to involve something other than their body.

Make help specific and optional. Would company on a walk feel good? Would sharing a meal, helping with an appointment or leaving the subject alone be more useful? The answer may change. Support works better when it responds to the person than when it follows a script about what weight loss should look like.

For more on the emotional adjustment itself, see psychologist Nusha Nouhi’s conversation about body image, relationships and changing routines. It explores why a visible change does not settle every feeling about the body.

Use biology to make room for care, rather than to label a person

Knapp describes having a stronger appetite than his siblings and feeling different from a young age. He later came to understand medication as something that could make certain eating decisions more manageable, rather than proof that his earlier effort had been worthless.

His explanation is personal. It does not establish that every person with obesity has the same hormone deficiency or that a test can identify a custom mixture of hormones to replace. The NIDDK’s discussion of factors affecting weight includes genes, environment, sleep, medicines, health conditions and everyday habits. A single story cannot sort out those contributions for another person.

That complexity is a reason to support an individualized assessment. It also leaves room for practical changes without making them a moral test. Ana and Knapp discuss barriers such as a neighborhood without convenient walking routes and Iowa winters that make outdoor activity difficult. A plan has to work where someone actually lives.

Help turn fast-moving news into a better appointment question

The interview also contains forecasts about oral medicines, combination drugs and procedures for maintenance. They reflect expectations at the time of recording, rather than a current approval list or a promise about when a particular person will gain access.

When a headline interests you, separate what was studied from what is available. Was the result in people, which people took part, what was the comparison and how long were they followed? For a drug, check its actual approval and prescribing information. The FDA’s drug-development overview distinguishes research from the agency’s review and approval decision.

A trial announcement can be a starting point for a clinician question; it should not become a reason to delay needed care or switch someone else’s treatment. Knapp’s enthusiasm about the pipeline is valuable as curiosity and hope, with those limits kept visible.

For an individual account of changing formulations, our conversation with Whitney Black about switching to an oral GLP-1 distinguishes her experience from a comparison of treatments. Different delivery methods can raise different practical and medical questions.

Stay interested after the first visible change

On The Pen grew partly because access was difficult: people needed help understanding insurance, savings programs and where to find treatment. Knapp’s community was responding to those practical obstacles, rather than only sharing before-and-after results.

That is a useful model for a family member or friend. Ask what is hard now. The answer might be an administrative problem, a change in eating, worry about other people’s reactions or the effort of continuing care when the early excitement has faded.

You do not need to become the prescriber or the food monitor. You can be someone who listens to the actual problem, offers help with permission and remains interested in the person’s life beyond their weight.